examples of journal article reviews

examples of journal article reviews

A Comprehensive Guide to Writing Journal Article Reviews

1. Introduction to Journal Article Reviews

Journal article reviews play an important role in the academic world. It is true that during your academic career you may do some similar things that aim to get similar results, but this is not what a journal article review does. A journal article review is a purely descriptive task – it does not contain any argument to offer examples or proof, as well as the book or article itself. While a journal article review critiques and evaluates an article objectively, your piece should report your own thoughts and experiences. You will want to suggest information in essays but you will not be backing up statistics from reliable sources or referring to other academic documents, only to the article or book that you are discussing.

Journal article reviews refer to the process of reviewing and analyzing the academic article that the student has chosen. You can review the article for various college classes, and generally at the college level, but not for publications or contents that are widely available. For example, with interdisciplinary issues, you do not even write an article review for the latest issue of your favorite magazine. Thus, journal article college reviews that you will write are opinion pieces that you write based on an article that you typically access from a certain database.

2. Key Components of a Journal Article Review

5. Conclusion. Summarize the review. Using up one or two paragraphs, offer an overall assessment of the report. This can be a comment on the research question, the theory, the sample, the identification of the data, the empirical results, etc. It could also be recommendations for further research or reflect upon the importance of the inquiry specifically. These recommendations should clearly be visible in the text and should be substantiated by specific references to the report. Your conclusions should flow logically from the reviewed report. Your conclusion can be helped by the overall stepwise approach outlined earlier.

4. Findings. This is the most important part of the review. Spend most of the time discussing the main findings, not any other related research information. Provide the reader with an understanding of what is there in the article; however, you will not have space to discuss everything. When finished, the reader should have a thorough knowledge of the content, how it is structured, and each of the arguments made and the conclusions that follow.

3. Method or Approach. It is important to be able to explain the method or analytical techniques used by the writer to arrive at their conclusions, and their justification for adopting these approaches. Usually identified in the Literature Review. This section of the article can also be found in the methods section. It may specify the data source, empirical model, econometric or theoretical framework used by the research or the approach.

2. Aims or scope of the research. Usually identified in the Introduction or Statement of Purpose, this information may be stated differently in different articles. It could be a hypothesis, a problem, a question, a theory, a model, etc., or the specific part of the study being researched. These purposes could help identify those articles that are within the scope of your review.

1. Introduction. You will begin writing your journal article review with a brief summary of the research question, problem, or issue addressed by the research. The content of the article must be summarized very succinctly, presenting only the main question or problem under investigation and some essential background that is necessary for the following discussion (two or three paragraphs). Remember, you are not being asked to give your opinion on the article.

3. Strategies for Analyzing and Critiquing the Article

Prior to reading the substance of the journal article, writing the review may be useful. A strategy for reading the article is needed, and one can turn to personal structures in Forman (1996) and Metis in summary writing to customize your background knowledge for analysis. As you read the article, think about the types of things you will need to write a comprehensive review. When you see the item, ask: What is the purpose of this opening section? What information does it contain? Do I understand what the writer meant? As a background for making the review valid, use what you know about Forman’s concepts of determining what is important in the problem analyzed and in clarifying some of the primary reasons it was analyzed.

Critiquing the article, not just reporting it, is a vital element of the journal review process. The biggest problem of not critiquing is that the writer cannot apply the information from the article to his/her own life situation. To aid the public, a critique can also validate the published document, especially when the review reveals the document’s benefits.

4. Tips for Writing a Clear and Concise Review

Conduct an article review before you use the article in a paper or class assignment. The review offers a judgment, a lot of times written in a specific academic style. If you want to learn how to critique an article, you should first have a clear understanding of what this assignment is about. Generally, it is an objective analysis of any piece of work. This sort of academic task focuses more on the summary of an article. It is suggested that you aim to embody a perfect balance between the critique and the summary. To ensure that you get access to the best essay article review assistance, stick to the instructions below. With experience and an “eye” for critical analysis, it is a perfect way for practicing evaluating your own job. To get other examples, check out our various examples.

When writing an article review, you will summarize the main ideas, arguments, positions, and findings, and then critique the article’s contributions and implications. Article critiques vary broadly. While each has an individual style and a different structure, they all provide several common elements. No matter whether you need to write a summary of the article, critique it, or analyze its weaknesses, there is the right approach to your article critique paper.