article review worksheet

article review worksheet

The Importance of Article Review in Academic Writing

1. Introduction

It is interesting that every individual knows what an article is, but when it comes to an academic article, it is not as easily understood. This is due to the fact that reading an academic article is not something commonly done. It is often too difficult for some people, especially those who are not used to digesting heavy materials in advanced English. However, those who are involved in the academic research world will certainly understand the significance of an academic article, especially one that is published in scientific journals. This is because an academic article contains information that has gone through research and is knowledge-based. Information and knowledge have always been the power of a person and a country. With them, a person can solve their problems and develop their life. The same thing happens to a country. By using information and knowledge, a country can solve all the problems it faces and bring goodness to its people. To obtain all of this information and knowledge, research should be done. The research results will be published in many forms, one of which is an academic article. With the article published, the knowledge and information can be transferred to the people who need it. This is the reason why an academic article is very precious and, in the end, should be easy to understand by everyone.

2. Benefits of Article Review

There are useful benefits for performing article review. First, you are able to get the information about the newest issue or information in a short time, as the journals are published within a short time from the issue. By making an article review, you will know the theoretical framework, methodology, findings, and the recommendations from the article that you have reviewed. This will make you able to compare the information from the old ones. Then, you can seek the relevant information according to the newest issue, as by comparing with the old ones, you can get the same topic with the newest issue. So, this will help you to solve the problem through all the similar steps that were written in the article, or you can do the innovations with the better steps. Finally, you will not lack the newest information for the specific topic, and this will help you to avoid obsolescence. Another benefit is you can develop your critical thinking and analytical skills. Critical thinking is the ability for making a systematic and highly logical assessment of a problem, using the awareness of the diversity in solving the problem, and using empathy aiming to implement the best solution. Meanwhile, analytical skill is the ability to use the method to solve complex problems, make decisions, and discover new problems. By comparing the information from the article that you have reviewed with others, this will train both skills, as you should capture the important information from the old ones and seek the same relevant information. Then, you can propose a solution to the specific problem and monitor the impact from the solution. This process, of course, will be very useful for your daily activity and personal development.

3. How to Conduct an Effective Article Review

Having additional review guidelines is most effective. You must be convinced to look up and analyze more information that will assist you in comprehending and critically analyzing the article. The article review usually goes in-depth, and therefore knowing new knowledge on the topic is very important in understanding more. The simpler ones tend to not be as efficient due to having minimal resources and knowledge when critiquing the article. More complex reviews, however, show great development and understanding of the topic and its relation to the article in question. Access to more information can come in the form of a discussion with the professor, asking questions, and possibly attaining an alternate view to what was previously held. Being active in the review shows that you are interested in the material and are willing to put the effort in to understand it better.

4. Common Mistakes to Avoid in Article Review

A second common mistake occurs when reviewers and editors spend a significant amount of time correcting language and grammar, often at the expense of conducting a thorough evaluation in their primary areas of expertise. Those submitting manuscripts should know that it is unrealistic to expect reviewers to ignore mistakes which hinder understanding, but they may certainly expect to have fewer language-related revisions and more substantial feedback by avoiding this mistake.

The first common mistake concerns the failure to enable proper understanding of the context, which significantly impedes any reader’s ability to understand and subsequently respond to the manuscript. Typical indicators of this mistake are a need for the author to follow up with lengthy explanations for various points throughout the manuscript, or having reviewers and editors make frequent conflicting or tangential comments.

When preparing to write your article review, keep in mind that there is a strong likelihood of making one or more of these mistakes. Thoroughly read to discover not only what a particular mistake is, but possible alternative strategies for behavior in the peer review process to improve overall results.

5. Conclusion

After we have briefly discussed the article review, we have come up with a conclusion at this point. Article review is very important and widely used in practice, especially in an academic environment. It can ensure that everyone from students to researchers can understand more about a specific article, journal, or even a book. We will know the brief summary of the article without needing to read the whole thing, which will save a lot of time. Then we can decide whether the article is worth using as a reference or not. We can compare it with other articles on the same topic. We can also identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article, so the author can learn from their mistakes and receive feedback. It is important to know how to make a good article review because it is not just summarizing the article, but analyzing it using critical thinking. If we can use it well, this can be good practice for our logic and critical thinking. There are also many methods to make an article review, depending on the goal or type of the article. The name of the article review can also be changed to another name, for example, “literature survey,” but it still serves the same purpose as the article review.